Next Salon Discussion

First Tuesday current affairs discussion - Tuesday 3 September 7:00pm start
PDF Print E-mail
Recent Discussions

Fukushima fallout

October 2011

Dr John Roberts, Dame Sue Ion and Rob Lyons introduced a discussion about where the fallout from Fukushima leaves the future of nuclear energy, chaired by Tony Gilland.

John Roberts

This year's earthquake off the northeastern coast of Japan, and the subsequent tsunami, had a devastating effect on that country, including the highly-publicised damage to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant. In the days and weeks following the earthquake, press coverage of the plant was intense, with many predicting a catastrophe - especially as some parts of the plant dated back to 1967.


Dame Sue IonFears of a 'new Chernobyl' spread across the globe. The fallout from the disaster has included Germany shutting down some of its plants and declaring all will be shut down by 2022. Meanwhile, some environmentalists who had recently begun to support nuclear power as an alternative to fossil fuels are having doubts, or simply reverting to the anti-nuclear position.


With the prospect of oil and gas production declining, with coal widely seen as unacceptable and alternative forms of 'green' energy production seemingly unable to satisfy increasing demands, the nuclear option had looked set for a renaissance.


Rob LyonsWill the new political climate allow the expansion of nuclear power that would be required to meet demand? What if any are the barriers to long-term safety? Will scientists be able to convince a sceptical public of the merits of nuclear power over traditional or other 'green' technologies still in their infancy? Are politicians willing to discuss the scientific merits or otherwise of nuclear power more openly, and help develop a balanced approach to political decision-making about energy?


This discussion will be preluded with a short presentation by the science writer Stephen Purver, on the wider effects of the Tōhoku earthquake and subsequent tsunami in March 2011.


Some background readings

Japan nuclear crisis should not carry weight in atomic energy debate, George Monbiot, Guardian 16 March 2011

What we know, and don't know, about Japan's reactors, by David L Chandler, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 16 March 2011

Japan: Nuclear panic is 'over-reaction' says scientists, Channel 4 News 17 March 2011

Why Fukushima made me stop worrying and love nuclear power, George Monbiot, Guardian 21 March 2011

The dangers of nuclear power in light of Fukushima, by Mark Lynas and Chris Goodall, Mark Lynas blog 30 March 2011

Nuclear energy: clean, reliable and powerful, Rob Lyons, spiked online 15 April 2011

Why Germany said no to nuclear power, by Daniel Johnson, The Telegraph 30 May 2011

European Pressurized Reactor, published on Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Japan PM calls for nuclear-free future, Guardian, 13 July 2011

After Fukushima: The Fear Factor, WORLDbytes video report, August 2011

After Fukushima, we should abandon nuclear power”, Debating Matters Topic Guide by Tony Gilland August 2011


Listen again (variable quality)...

Speakers on Fukushima fallout - click on the Play button:


Audience discussion on Fukushima fallout - click on the Play button:


View again (from NLTV)


Original video of Manchester Salon's 'Fukushima fallout' discussion produced by NLTV

Discussion Partners

Battle of IdeasThis discussion is a satellite event of the prestigious Battle of Ideas 2011 weekend festival of ideas being held on 29 and 30 October 2011, hosted by the Royal College of Art, London. Now in its seventh year, the Battle of Ideas festival comprises 75 debates and satellite discussions confronting society’s big issues and unresolved questions. It affords the opportunity for some clear thinking, rational debate and agenda-setting - above all, it's future-orientated, whilst retaining a healthy regard for the past achievements of humanity.

Manchester Science Festival

For the second year, the Manchester Salon is participating in the fabulous Manchester Science Festival, which is celebrating its fifth year. With over 200 events for families and adults, you can expect an exciting nine days of cutting-edge research, the brightest minds and amazing events. You’ll have the chance to delve into immersive experiences, explore the science of the city by foot, join in the debate, enjoy hands-on activities, see awe-inspiring films and much more. Watch out for trailblazers throughout the year and join us at events throughout Greater Manchester during 22 – 30 October 2011.


Discussion Sponsors

Urbanization Architects Urbanization Architects is a recently founded architectural practice, based in Manchester, currently undertaking a range of commissions in the residential, domestic and commercial sectors.

Urbanization upholds the imperative for the advancement and development of the built environment in order to create the spaces, structures and infrastructure required to support the needs of a progressive society.


PG Stage theatre lighting PG Stage has a wealth of experience spanning over 30 years in supplying, designing and installing Theatre and Stage Lighting Systems, Sound and AV Systems Design. Based in Manchester, PG Stage undertake projects across Manchester, London and all across the UK as well as overseas, they install systems in a wide range of unique venues; ranging from theatres, to cinemas, to schools, and much more in between.

Being an NICEIC approved company, their fully qualified team are professional, flexible and considerate, providing comprehensive project management right the way through the process.



If you would like to sponsor future discussions, or partner in promoting them, please get in touch via the sponsorship page or the sponsor the Salon form.

Join the Salon Email List
Youtube Video of discussion on Energy
RSS Feed for discussions
Manchester Salon Facebook Group
Manchester Salon Facebook Page
Manchester Salon on Twitter